Reproductive success of broiler breeders in natural mating systems: the effect of male-male competition, sperm quality, and morphological characteristics

University of Maryland, Animal and Avian Sciences, College Park, Maryland 20742, USA.

In natural mating systems in which broiler breeder males compete for females, reproductive behavior plays an important role in male fertility, along with sperm competition and morphological and physiological characteristics. We investigated the effect of male-male competition compared with a noncompetitive situation on fertility, sperm quality, and morphological traits. Six groups of 3 males and 12 females were housed in mixed-sex pens. Their frequency of mating was recorded, and progeny of each male was determined through DNA fingerprinting. Males with the highest and the lowest mating frequencies were later placed into groups of 1 male and 4 females, their behavior was recorded, and their fertility was calculated. We collected data on semen quality (semen volume, sperm concentration, and mobility) and morphometrical characters. Finally, females were artificially inseminated with sperm from highest frequency, lowest frequency, or a mix, paternity and fertility were estimated. Our results indicate that heavier males had higher frequency of matings without cloacal contact, and males with smaller combs had more mating attempts. We also detected that males with high sperm concentration had lower fertility. However, we found an overall lack of association between mating behavior, morphometrical traits, sperm quality, and fertility. This, together with the discrepancy of results in fertility when compared with artificial insemination conditions, suggest a multifactorial nature of the fertility of broiler breeder males in natural mating systems. In addition we observed a high male fertility when housed individually, suggesting that male fertility is a relative parameter that depends upon the reproductive quality of the other male competitors within the group.